Homo Vitruvius and American Samizdat function properties for my weekly inventive writing and mental exploration. HV persists as my authentic and first Substack in these pursuits; AS arose in resistance to Trumpism and is devoted to its defeat. From memoir and poetry to fiction and drama, principally in HV, to historical past and political philosophy, predominantly in AS, you’ll discover it right here, built-in throughout the 2 stacks via a inventive and mental sensibility I hope you’ll discover invigorating. The stacks could also be subscribed collectively or singly in Handle Subscription.
Your help for my writing on these two stacks lifts me up. Your readership and your likes, your feedback, shares, and suggestions, and your free and paid subscriptions allow me within the inventive challenge of my writing life and in my mission to supply a renascent mild towards the darkness: artwork, data, tradition, and concepts for a free, tolerant, and democratic folks. Thanks in your curiosity and help.
The primary arduous reality, the foundational reality, is how unprepared People and the USA authorities had been for what’s occurred. The world’s longest-running democracy, vaunted in its personal collective consciousness and nationwide mythos as the best democracy — as distinctive — collapsed within the face of baldfaced and brute authoritarian corruption and lies, after 235 years, in lower than even a decade.
The nation’s cherished and historic establishments, held up as instance to the world, proved far weaker than complacently imagined — by no means the bulwark towards tyranny that the founders and the Constitutionalists and institutionalists relied on. One of many nation’s two institutionalized political events shortly succumbed to deprave opportunism and authoritarianism. The nation’s citizenry, among the many least civically engaged of the world’s liberal democracies, proved itself — towards its lengthy, inherited legacy — to be considerably unprepared for a democratic world energy’s sensible stewardship of its grave duties.
The nation’s conventional, profit-driven, journalistic and mass media institutions, mired in standard and more and more outworn practices unequal to the historic second, failed to face not simply as promised pillars but additionally as stalwart defenders of liberal democracy.
Within the face of Trumpist intimidation, they retreat or stay cautious, more and more complicit.
Institutional fecklessness and failure enabled the rise of the Nazis in Germany, too.
Instantly after coming to energy, the management of the Nationwide Socialist German Staff’ Occasion (NSDAP) started to remove these organizations that threatened to oppose its declare to totality. An adaptation of all state and social establishments to the political and ideological targets of the NSDAP was supposed to switch the pluralistic variety of the Weimar Republic.
The time period that was coined to specific this enforced conformity was first utilized in March and April 1933: gleichschaltung, which suggests “coordination” or “synchronization” – a bringing of all social and political parts into line. This included the impartial press.
When all different political events had been outlawed, so too had been the newspapers they produced. The Nazi Occasion drove different, competing newspapers out of enterprise and assumed clandestine possession of nonetheless extra.
Shortly after taking energy in January 1933, Adolf Hitler and the Nazis succeeded in destroying Germany’s vibrant and various newspaper tradition. The newly created Ministry of Public Enlightenment and Propaganda handed out each day directions to all German newspapers, Nazi or impartial, detailing how the information was to be reported.
. . . .
Some impartial newspapers, significantly conservative newspapers and non-political illustrated weeklies, accommodated the regime via self-censorship or initiative in coping with accredited matters.
Will we not see already these sorts of developments, or the immanence of them, simply within the first three months of the Trump regime?
Editors are particularly certain to maintain out of the newspapers something which: (…) tends to weaken the power of the German Reich, outwardly or inwardly, the frequent will of the German folks, the German protection means, tradition, or economic system, or offends the non secular sentiments of others.
Editor’s Regulation, of October 4, 1933, Part 14
Propaganda Ministry, Reich Press Chamber, Reich Affiliation of the German Press
——–
(iii) take motion, as acceptable and according to relevant regulation, to make sure that all public monuments, memorials, statues, markers, or comparable properties inside the Division of the Inside’s jurisdiction don’t include descriptions, depictions, or different content material that inappropriately disparage People previous or residing (together with individuals residing in colonial instances), and as a substitute give attention to the greatness of the achievements and progress of the American folks or, with respect to pure options, the wonder, abundance, and grandeur of the American panorama.
Restoring Reality and Sanity to American Historical past
Donald J. Trump, Govt Orders, March 27, 2025
The nation’s authorized institution, already sullied by blatant monetary and ideological corruption and resistance to accountability within the Supreme Courtroom, has over latest weeks delivered account after account of main regulation companies, among the many most resource-empowered and litigation-capable within the land, complying prematurely, providing assist, bending earlier than intimidation, as a way to preserve their standing. We see this, too, in Nazi Germany.
[L]ike most areas of public life after the Nazi rise to energy in 1933, the German system of justice underwent “coordination” [gleichschaltung]. All skilled associations concerned with the administration of justice had been merged into the Nationwide Socialist League of German Jurists.
The US Holocaust Memorial Museum tells us,
The position of these within the authorized career typically and the actions of judges specifically had been important. Conforming to new legal guidelines, decrees, and norms, attorneys helped to oust Jewish colleagues from the courts, skilled associations, and regulation companies. They had been motivated by prejudice towards Jews and new alternatives that opened up for his or her profession {and professional} development.
In “Judges, Attorneys, Authorized Theorists, and the Regulation in Nazi Germany (1933–1938),” Justice Richard D. Fybel poses the query, “How did the authorized system in Germany allow the deprivation of the rights of Jews and, finally, the Holocaust?”
The core reply, as this Essay will clarify, is that German society—together with, shamefully, the courts, judges, attorneys, and authorized theorists—accepted and in lots of circumstances promoted Nazi energy and race-based injustice. Adolf Hitler’s absolute energy as Führer was achieved incrementally, in plain sight, and purportedly underneath regulation.
Cynthia Fountaine of the College of North Texas, within the St. Mary’s Journal on Authorized Malpractice & Ethics, titles her paper, “Complicity within the Perversion of Justice: The Function of Attorneys in Eroding the Rule of Regulation within the Third Reich.”
Ingo Müller was blunter within the German title of his guide, Abominable Attorneys, retitled within the U.S, Hitler’s Justice: The Courts of the Third Reich. Has it not been made abundantly clear these previous three months, after years earlier than, that the present President of the USA intends to ship “Trump’s Justice”?
This survey of the German authorized system earlier than, throughout, and after Hitler’s rule throughout the Third Reich reminds readers how fragile the safeguards of a civilized society might be when the authorized system can not, or doesn’t, resist rampant misrule.
The American Oligarchs, Musk, Bezos, Zuckerberg, Thiel, Sachs, Cook dinner, Mellon, Adelson, Marcus, Ricketts, Penske, Wynn, Web page, Brin add their and their corporations’ names to these notorious consorters and conspirers with evil, within the accounts and the lists of the companies and monied pursuits that supported Naziism and helped construct its nationwide and industrial infrastructure.
Enterprise collaboration with Nazi Germany
Record of corporations concerned within the Holocaust
Then we come to the arduous reality – arduous, arduous reality – of our fellow People. They’ve their precedents to, within the sins they’ve already dedicated, within the wrongs to return, in nations all around the world — and in Nazi Germany, By the tip of the Second World Battle, the Nazi Occasion had a membership of 8 million — lots of people, although solely 10% of the German inhabitants, and we all know that lots of these memberships had been of varied sorts of fearful and compulsory conformity. However that didn’t matter. Their memberships upheld the celebration’s authority and energy. And a German citizen of the frequent rung, protecting his head down, minding her family enterprise, not one to become involved or have interaction within the wrestle, didn’t should belong to the celebration to sympathize, to tell, to betray, to smell the air in suspicion of a Jew, a communist, a dissident — to look the opposite manner when somebody was taken away.
Because the U.S. Holocaust Museum tells us, “Some Had been Neighbors: Collaboration and Complicity within the Holocaust,”
After the conflict many odd Germans and Europeans claimed that they had been “not concerned” in Nazi crimes. The development of such postwar recollections—and abdication of any accountability for what occurred—belies the fact of the widespread, typically energetic involvement of individuals in any respect ranges of German society and past. Many onlookers to occasions who accredited or tolerated what they witnessed with out expressing dissent had been additionally “concerned” in making the Holocaust attainable.
Inside Nazi Germany many people grew to become energetic or semi-active individuals in Nazi racial and antisemitic insurance policies aimed first on the isolation, impoverishment, and compelled emigration of German Jews throughout the Nineteen Thirties, then throughout World Battle II (1939–1945), the annihilation of European Jewry. They included civil servants engaged of their “regular work” equivalent to finance officers processing the steep “tax on Jewish wealth” levied in 1938 or inventorying property seized following the wartime deportations; clerks who saved recordsdata of paperwork itemizing “race” or “faith” and addresses utilized in police roundups; academics in any respect instructional ranges whose classes included racist and antisemitic content material. Particular person residents selected to be “concerned” once they voluntarily denounced their co-workers and neighbors to the police due to their alleged transgressions as Jews, “buddies of Jews,” anti-Hitlerites, or gays.
Among the many books the Holocaust Encyclopedia recommends on the topic are:
-
Barnett, Victoria. Bystanders: Conscience and Complicity throughout the Holocaust. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1999.
-
Feldman, Gerald D. and Wolfgang Seibel, Networks of Nazi Persecution: Paperwork, Enterprise and the Group of the Holocaust. New York: Berghahn Books, 2005.
-
Fullbrook, Mary. A Small City Close to Auschwitz: Extraordinary Nazis and the Holocaust. Oxford, UK: Oxford College Press, 2012.
HARD TRUTH — A lot of our fellow People now embrace fascism. They’re fascist.
To be clear, after I say fascism right here, I imply not actually believing in a typical, inclusive concept of freedom. There may be the pretense, the self-delusion of believing in freedom, however probably not, and in lots of circumstances by no means. Believing as a substitute in dominating authority, in authoritarianism, within the type of a charismatic particular person and omnipotent celebration. Now not believing within the rule of regulation, even when it doesn’t go your manner, not believing in tolerance of the completely different and divergent however retreating as a substitute into offended and resentful, slender notions of a real (German, Italian, Spaniard, Moslem, native-born, Christian, white American). The pretense of religiosity draping the worst corruptions of the spirit — the unholy need to dominate those that reject the official religion, with cruelty towards them. Now not believing in democracy.
I might go on. This can do for now. Learn:
Sure, many Trump supporters, marginal voters, are actually ignorant. They know little about authorities, politics, and coverage, and are simply swayed to make poor decisions.
Many Trump supporters are fools. People are silly creatures. Assist for fascism, any type of authoritarianism, each time and in all places it arises is foolishness writ traditionally giant.
In most respects, even within the down instances, the mass of People over the previous 75 years have had it higher than any folks within the historical past of the planet. And 77 million of them determined after ten years of attending to know Donald Trump — it was all there for the understanding, simply to begin in the way in which he spoke to and about folks — that quite the opposite, they really had it so dangerous, that they’d to decide on him and throw away the achievement, such because it has been, of 235 years of imperfect however increasing freedom, democracy, and well-being.
You’ll be able to’t get extra silly than that.
So, sure, there are the ignorant and the silly and perhaps they are often persuaded, if by nothing else however their self-interest. If it takes their very own monetary or household misfortune, so be it. Persuade them for those who can.
However hundreds of thousands of Trump voters know precisely who he’s and what he represents, and they like that. They need it. The proof of that’s plentiful. For ten years, democrats waited for voters lastly to see, to grasp.
His vote depend grew.
They’re fascists. A good portion of the American inhabitants has been received over to fascism.
Regardless of the purpose they’ve internalized and provide as rationalization, as excuse: they resent unlawful immigrants, they resent “elites” and massive cities. They hate “DEI” and id politics and “wokeism.” Nonetheless respectable a few of their complaints may be. In the event that they hate any of these issues a lot that they select Trump and all he brings and dropped at America — they’re fascists.
That’s what it means, traditionally, empirically, to be fascist. To react towards a monetary hardship or cultural change or a bogeyman of communism or Marxism or “woke cultural Marxism” — all of which did and do exist — and to react towards them so strongly that one chooses as a substitute Mussolini, Hitler, Franco, Pinochet, Trump.
The worst a part of it, all the time?
They’re folks you already know. Household, buddies, colleagues — fellow Substackers. It was like that in Italy, in Germany, Spain and Portugal. (Sure, Portugal was fascist, too, concurrently with Spain.)
And they need issues to proceed as regular between the 2 of you. They appear, in methods, nonetheless the identical enjoyable, affable, maybe-even-personally-kind people they’ve all the time been. And also you need issues to proceed as regular, too, as a result of, nicely, that’s simply the way in which you might be. Nobody desires to reject household, previous buddies, folks we all the time preferred previously. We cling to human connection. We don’t wish to be those who break it.
However as good as these folks you used to know appear nonetheless to be, personally, they voted for and nonetheless help somebody who’s destroying the entire edifice of our Constitutional democracy round us, violating any regulation he chooses a number of instances a day, arresting folks unlawfully, chaining them and sleep depriving them at border crossings, delivery folks off to overseas prisons with out due course of for publicly-televised humiliation, focusing on as enemies, and endangering their lives, different politicians, the press, regulation companies that oppose him, lifelong public servants and army leaders.
These good, affable individuals are supporting that — they’ll help extra – extra is coming – simply as they all the time have previously.
And the foremost purpose they need the whole lot to proceed as regular between you is in order that they don’t should face themselves in your rejection, the rejection we predict (don’t we?) any really good Germans ought to have delivered to their fellow, fascist Germans — rejected of their Nazi sympathy, spurned of their solicitation of understanding, shamed for his or her help and complicity in tyranny.
The pretense that there’s nothing fallacious with what they’ve come to imagine and help.
The cruelties dedicated of their identify.
The longer we preserve treating the fascists as regular, making all of it appear okay, similar to the previous days, when Democrats and Republicans, liberals and conservatives, was once proud to be buddies with one another, as demonstration of their tolerance and civility — their democratic comity and private decency — the longer we allow them to assume what they imagine and countenance is regular.
Your fascist buddies wish to faux it’s nonetheless like that. They wish to create that phantasm. That it’s okay. (Look, we will nonetheless discuss! Sorry you misplaced your job, your social safety, your child bought arrested.) It helps them sleep.
It additionally places you to sleep, in your personal delusion, whereas all is misplaced round us.
As a result of the ultimate arduous reality is that when fascism comes, it comes with a reckoning, and the reckoning can’t be evaded, even when the determined hope that it may be is clung to love a pillow in a stressed dream. You rise up otherwise you fall down. You fall down till they arrive for you, or somebody you already know, or somebody that you already know is aware of. And then you definitely disguise for the remainder of your life from what you probably did and didn’t do. You disguise till you die, mendacity about who you might be — in a different way to completely different folks. Or in the long run, ultimately, some type of rescue by some means comes, and you must lie once more, a nonetheless completely different manner, about what you probably did or didn’t do. Fake a distinct previous, all the time in worry of publicity and disgrace.
I’m not making any of this up. It requires no creativeness. It’s the historical past of Nazi and postwar Germany, of Italy, of France: See Marcel Ophuls’ epic documentary The Sorrow and the Pity concerning the French Resistance — and non-resistance.
The shameless, relentless Trump and the brute horde of authoritarians who’ve gathered round him, the ideologues of Undertaking 2025 and the Federalist Society and CPAC — do we predict they’ve labored all these many years to seize this energy after which simply give it up by a choose’s order, a Supreme Courtroom’s choice?
Do we predict that now, with close to complete management of the manager department, the nationwide legislature, and the Supreme Courtroom, Trump and his gang will allow one other free election through which they may lose all of it — settle for an consequence they don’t like? After what they did, when far much less {powerful}, on January 6?
Have we realized nothing?
Day-after-day, Trump and people round him acquire extra energy. Day-after-day the possibility of surviving the onslaught diminishes.
That is it. That is the second.
Rise up.
Fall down.
AJA
